Why Your Friendships Don’t Look Like the Movies

Friendship IRL podcast promotional graphic for Episode 198. The graphic features a textured teal-green background with a distressed, grainy overlay throughout. At the top center, a large bold orange number

APPLE PODCAST | SPOTIFY


Have you ever watched a video online, felt a pang of longing, and then spent the next hour quietly convinced that something was missing from your life? That’s where this episode starts. Alex was scrolling through social media when a reel popped up: a woman who’d invited all her friends to meet at a diner at seven a.m. before work. And instead of just smiling and scrolling past, Alex felt it. That familiar ache of “why don’t my friendships look like that?”

She had what she was looking for. She just couldn’t see it yet.

This episode of Friendship IRL is about friendship expectations vs. reality: where those expectations come from, why the gap between the dream and your actual life isn’t evidence of failure, and how to start seeing what you’ve already built.


Where the Dream Version Comes From

For Alex, it was Seinfeld. Her mom loved the show, and growing up, she watched Jerry, Elaine, George, and Kramer wander in and out of each other’s apartments and meet at the diner before work like it was nothing. Multiple times a week. Just… there, in each other’s lives.

That image lodged itself somewhere deep, the way these things do.

Maybe for you it’s a different show. Friends and the open-door apartment situation is a big one. Or the girls’ trip reel. The multi-family vacation. The group of guys who golf every weekend. Whatever the image is, it got in early, and now it sits in the back of your mind as the benchmark your real friendships get measured against.

The problem isn’t wanting those things. Alex is clear about that: wanting them is actually great. The problem is when we hold up that curated, scripted, 90-second version of friendship next to our actual messy, logistically complicated, season-specific lives, and decide something is wrong with us.


Your Friendships Look Like Your Life

Here is the point at the center of this episode: your friendships look like your life. The mix of people you’re close to right now, what you do together, how often you see each other, all of it is the direct result of a thousand small and large decisions you’ve made. Where you live. How you work. What you’ve been through. What you’ve prioritized.

Alex walked through her own version of this. She’s self-employed, which gives her flexibility her corporate-job friends don’t have. Over the last few years, she made a deliberate push to build more in-person entrepreneurial friendships: joining networking groups, showing up to events, prioritizing those connections. And while she was recording the episode, a group text was actively lighting up with entrepreneurial women friends planning to attend a networking event together and get lunch after.

She had been watching that diner reel wishing for something she already had. It just didn’t look like Seinfeld. It looked like meeting at a coffee shop at nine a.m., putting headphones in, working side by side, talking through business problems. Same energy. Different image.

The reason she didn’t clock it immediately? The picture in her head didn’t match. And that mismatch is doing a lot of damage for a lot of people.

In the full episode, Alex traces her own friendship gap back to the specific choices that created it, and why seeing that connection shifts how you think about what you have.


The Seasons Keep Shifting

One of the most honest sections of this episode is when Alex talks about the reality of seasons of friendship and how the shape of your social life changes roughly every three to five years, whether you planned for it or not.

Right now, she’s in a season where a lot of her friends have young kids. The big annual group trips that used to happen every year? They’ve slowed down. Getting five families to commit to the same weekend is a logistical puzzle that doesn’t always get solved. She’d be lying if she said she didn’t picture this season differently.

But she also knows that in five or ten years, those kids will be teenagers. More independent. And the ease of getting everyone in one place will come back. She’s genuinely hopeful about that, and she’s not spending this season grinding her teeth waiting for the next one.

What she’s doing instead is noticing what this season actually offers. Fewer big group trips means more one-on-one time with individual families. Smaller visits. Deeper conversations than she’d get in a week-long group situation. There’s real beauty in that, even if it wasn’t the plan.

The only constant in friendship is change. The parameters shift. What’s easy becomes hard. What felt impossible becomes natural. Holding your vision loosely enough to actually enjoy where you are right now is the skill.

Listen to the full episode for the conversation about how to hold a direction for your friendships without turning it into a blueprint that sets you up for disappointment.


The Money Analogy That Makes This Concrete

You have to look at your current budget AND your long-term retirement savings at the same time. You’re constantly weighing what you spend now against what you want later. A vacation now or a down payment later. A new car or a retirement account.

Your friendships work the same way.

You need to be present in the season you’re in, making choices that fit right now, while also keeping an eye on the direction you want to be heading. Both at once. And yes, it can feel like a lot at first, the same way learning to manage your finances felt overwhelming before it became second nature. But just like budgeting, it eventually moves closer to autopilot. Small reflections. Micro adjustments. The occasional bigger check-in. You start to develop a feel for whether you’re on track.

The goal isn’t a perfect friendship portfolio. It’s awareness of what you have, what you’re building toward, and the agency you actually have in both.


What to Do With the Gap

If you’ve been sitting with that feeling, the one that has you thinking “why don’t my friendships look like that?”, here’s where Alex lands:

You probably have more than you’re giving yourself credit for. The image in your head and the life you’re actually living might be closer than you think. Start looking at what you’ve actually built before deciding something is missing.

If there is a gap, you have more say than you realize. You can pick a direction. You can lead by example. You can be the one who texts and says “does anyone want to meet at a diner this week?” and see who shows up. You can’t control who says yes. But you can make the offer.

And you can hold it loosely. Whatever you think your friendships will look like in ten years, probably only about half of it will play out the way you imagined, even if you work toward it. That’s not a reason to stop wanting things. It’s a reason to stay curious instead of attached to a specific picture.

This season is fleeting. Find what’s good in it now, while also moving toward what you want. That’s the whole thing.

Listen to the full episode for the complete conversation about friendship expectations, seasons of friendship, and how to stop comparing your life to someone else’s highlight reel.


Keep the conversation going.

Hi. I'm Alex.

I’m obsessed with helping people build the support systems they actually need. Through my book, podcast, and community, I share the frameworks that transformed my life from lonely and overwhelmed to deeply supported.

What’s your take? Let me know in the comments below.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Hi. I'm Alex.

I believe everyone deserves a support system that actually holds them.

Friends to call after a rough day, emergency contacts, a neighbor who will grab your mail – I teach you how to create it all.

THE BOOK

ARE WE FRIENDS YET?

You're more connected than you think.

A free 10-day audio reset to help you notice the small, meaningful moments of connection already happening around you.

No homework. No pressure. Just small shifts that change everything.